Dr. Dobb's Journal
by Charlie Munro and Mark Nelson
This summer a remarkable thing happened in Dallas, and for once it didn’t have anything to do with triple digit temperatures or the Dallas Cowboys. In fact, this story didn’t even make the front page of the newspaper; it was buried in a garish Fry’s insert. What was it that made this advertisement newsworthy? Simply the news that an 18 GByte disk drive could be had for the price of $180.
What makes this price point so interesting is that it means we have now reached the point where a Megabyte of hard disk space can be had for the grand total of one cent. Doing The math led us to an inescapable conclusion: the ultimate home jukebox was now within our reach.
Laying down tracks
After a quick trip to Fry’s, followed by a few hours of rehab work on some older PCs, we had inexpensive home music servers that were ready to be loaded with our personal collections. The format of choice for recording music from CDs is MPEG-1 audio layer 3, popularly known as MP3. We found that most CDs can be digitally converted to MP3 format at a rate of 160 Kbps with no great loss of fidelity. (Trained ears or high quality audio gear might require higher rates.) This meant that our new 18Gbyte drives could hold up to 300 CDs, enough for a good-sized personal collection!
Creating MP3 recordings on your PC involves two steps: ripping and encoding. Ripping refers to the process of extracting the music from the CD itself. Ideally this is done digitally, reading the actual bits directly from disk. We were able to do digital ripping on most machines, most of the time, but in some situations had to fall back to analog ripping. This less-desirable method involves playing the CD tracks through your sound card, then digitizing its analog output. The slight loss of fidelity may be minimal, but it human psychology seems to magnify the loss out of proportion.
Once the tracks have been ripped to your hard disk, usually as WAV files, the encoder converts them to MP3 files. The MP3 files can be encoded at rates as low as 16 KBps ranging up to 320 Kbps. Our selected rate of 160 Kbps reduces the WAV file size by roughly 9 to 1.
Integrated programs that rip and encode generally also take advantage of online CD track databases. These databases keep playlists for as many titles as possible, and can be accessed via the Internet. (See www.cddb.com for more information on these databases.) The encoder can embed this track information in the MP3 file in an information element known as the ID3 tag.
A typical ripping session in progress is shown in Figure 1. The program in question, AudioCatalyst, is an integrated ripper/encoder from Xing, a company that is known for their multimedia compression and rendering engine.
Figure 1 — A rip/encode session in progress
The whole point of putting your entire CD collection on a hard drive is ease of access. Being able to play what you want, when you want, is like being the program director of your own radio station.
Making the database of music easy to work with involved a couple of different design decisions. The first decision we made was the naming scheme for the files and directories that would hold the music repository. Each CD was placed in its own directory, which fell under a virtual root using the directory naming scheme of Artist/Title. The individual songs were named according to the scheme Track Number — Title.mp3. A shot of the resulting organization is shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2 — The Music Repository Naming Scheme
This naming scheme was really designed for the human navigation. Regardless of the software we used to play our music, we knew we could find individual CDs or tracks quickly and easily. Using Windows drag and drop, it’s easy to quickly select individual tracks from a CD and drag them Onto a player. This gives us the convenience of a simple database without any real programming.
This directory structure is good, but scanning it when looking for music can be time consuming. Asking the operating system to traverse the structure with a library of several hundred CDs can mean minutes of disk activity. To avoid doing this constantly, we also created a single directory of M3U playlists. By making our Playlist folder a Virtual Directory on the web server, we’ll have an easy way to link to these files from a web page.
Most popular MP3 players (including Windows Media Player) support the M3U format, which is actually just an ASCII list of files. A typical M3U file is shown in Figure 3.
\\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\1_Planet Telex.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\2_The Bends.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\3_High And Dry.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\4_Fake Plastic Trees.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\5_Bones.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\6_(Nice Dream).mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\7_Just.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\8_My Iron Lung.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\9_Bullet Proof..I Wish I Was.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\10_Black Star.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\11_Sulk.mp3 \\mark\d\My Music\Radiohead\The Bends\12_Street Spirit (Fade Out).mp3
Note that the file names are given as network shared drives. This is critical for making your music playable on any system in your home network. It also allows us to expand our collection across disks or even machines. M3U files can be created using the command line DIR command, or using most popular players. We usually use WinAmp’s playlist editor to create ours.
The Friendly Front End
Once you’ve gone to the trouble of setting up a home music server, you probably are already thinking about serving up HTML pages from the same system. We thought it would be nice to have a web page that listed all your music in a somewhat organized form. Better yet, the web page ought to be able to dynamically create the index based on the contents of an M3U directory.
It takes a bit more than plain HTML to accomplish this, but nothing too sophisticated. Since we decided to implement our directory using Active Server Pages we were committed to using Microsoft’s servers. We’ve used both IIS and Microsoft’s Personal Web Server with good results.
Figure 4 shows a screen shot of the web page that organizes the music. Having the titles organized by artist, having all the artists in alphabetical order, and then having links that let you move quickly through the page all contribute to making it quick and easy to choose your selections. Each album name you see is a hot link to an M3U file. Clicking on it automatically launches your MP3 player and begins playing the CD.
Figure 4 — The Dynamically Generated Web Page
The Script Behind the Page
The routine that sets up all the data for this page to display is function
It uses an instance of the ASP
FileSystemObject to create a list of all the M3U files our
Playlist directory. The
Server.MapPath() method lets us get the path to the M3U files
from the virtual directory name. One thing to notice in the
GetFileList() function is the way
we loop through the files. Unlike VBScript, where you can iterate through members of a files
For Each Item In
Enumerator object for the files collection. We then use the
object.item() method to
set a variable to the current file object in the collection.
These file names are stored in array
fileList when the function is called near the top of the
array.sort() method. Since the file
names start with the artist, this clumps all the files for a given artist together in the list.
array.sort() method uses ASCII sorting
(A-Z before a-z) by default, it’s important to have all your file names start with uppercase letters.
After generating the HTML for the very start of the page, we create a dynamic list of hot links
to each of the possible first letters in the artists in the collection. Once the index of single
letter links has been written out, the rest of the page is created in a simple loop that iterates
over each file in the
fileList array. For every file in the list, we are going to create a
link on the web page that has the name of the CD (with the artist name stripped off) and points
to the M3U file. The code that does that is at the bottom of the loop:
In this part of the code, the title variable gets the album title portion of the file name, and
it is what is displayed. The full path name is used as the actual link, but this is simply our
virtual directory name and the file name. The formatting for the whole listing is accomplished
using Definition List block elements (
<DL>) for each letter, with each artist as a defined
<DT>) and each title as a definition (
We open and close the definition list elements using code executed conditionally at the top of
the loop. For each title, we check to see if the Artist has changed by comparing
artist. If the Artist has changed, we check to see if that artist
is the first to start with a new letter. If it is the first, we call
which closes out the current list (
<DL>) of titles, inserts a new anchor, starts
the next definition list, and returns. For each new artist, we insert the artist name as
a Defined Term (
<DT>). If the artist for the current file is the same as
lastArtist, then we write just the title as a definition (
MP3’ Tech at www.mp3tech.org provides a great
deal of technical and programming information regarding the MP3 format. MP3.com at
has links to popular freeware, shareware, and commercial players and track rippers. A
few of the programs we’ve had success with are listed below.
Xing Technology Corporation